24 Comments
User's avatar
Dusty Masterson's avatar

Great interview, thanks to both

Have cross posted

https://dustymasterson.substack.com/p/hobsons-choice-the-moon-in-a-puddle

Dusty

Susan McCarthy's avatar

Great episode, just listened today. Jenny and Carol (and all of your subscribers/fans), you will probably find this article from The Hill interesting. "Performative Virtue-signaling has Become a Threat to Higher Ed." The piece is depressing, yet the fact that it was published is encouraging.

https://thehill.com/opinion/education/5446702-performative-virtue-signaling-has-become-a-threat-to-higher-ed/

The piece draws on survey research. The researchers were not asking specifically about "politics," they were interested in psychological issues facing college students on campus. According to the researchers, "Our question was clinical, not political: 'What happens to identity formation when belief is replaced by adherence to orthodoxy?'"

Among their findings:

*88 percent of students surveyed answered "Yes" to the question "Have you ever pretended to hold more progressive views than you truly endorse to succeed socially or academically?

*77 percent said they disagreed with the idea that gender identity should override biological sex in such domains as sports, healthcare, or public data — but would never voice that disagreement aloud.

*38 percent described themselves as “morally confused,” uncertain whether honesty was still ethical if it meant exclusion.

This all seems very relevant especially given Carol's account of her cancellation by those kind, loving Unitarians, who clearly no longer regard honesty as an ethical stance.

The link to the Hill piece was posted on my Facebook feed by an FB friend, a political science professor at UC Berkeley. His one comment on the article: "Absolutely." So we liberal-lefty professors aren't all insane!

[Sorry for the overly long post, don't mean to hijack your substack, lol!]

Tenaciously Terfin's avatar

What a great discussion, thanks both. I was really interested to hear that Carol registers as a man on surveys. I’m sure I’d be the same thanks to my feisty Irish mother who refused to take any nonsense from anyone. And I agree, it’s not kind to lie to children. We all need to ‘live not by lies’.

I L's avatar

A great conversation.

Being shun away because people were captured by this horrendous ideologies is horrible.

Something needs to start happening and is that lobbies need to start being created a lobby protecting women’s existence and safety and rights the same thing for kids, safety and rights and family safeties and rights protections need to start forming in order to combat, this harmful gender trans ideology garbage.

EyesOpen's avatar

It is hard the believe that people can be such hypocrites as the members of that camp/church. But I can believe it because I have been treated similarly by other groups for the same reasons. We live in dystopian times.

Kathleen Lowrey's avatar

My mom was a UU for many years. Tithed, volunteered, hosted. She left over the gender stuff and wrote a thoughtful letter to the minister of her congregation explaining why.

No response. NOTHING. Not even a “sorry to see you go”.

We held my dad’s funeral service in the UU church to which they had long belonged in 2015. When my mother died in 2024 we had to hold it in the tiny chapel of her retirement centre, which overflowed the seating by a lot, and the minister who led it was a very nice man but hardly knew her and was an evangelical Christian.

I cannot begin to tell you how low an opinion I now have of the UUs.

Steersman's avatar

> "... low opinion of ... the UUs"

Sadly, religion in general. Pascal once said that men, and women, never do evil quite so completely and cheerfully as when they do so from religious conviction. And gender ideology has turned into a new religion.

Apropos of which, an old Guardian article on "the funniest religious joke of all time!" I had tweeted it to some woman who passed it along to some Baptist relatives of hers who read it out at some convocation of theirs -- apparently brought down the house:

QUOTE:

Once I saw this guy on a bridge about to jump. I said, "Don't do it!" He said, "Nobody loves me." I said, "God loves you. Do you believe in God?"

He said, "Yes." I said, "Are you a Christian or a Jew?" He said, "A Christian." I said, "Me, too! Protestant or Catholic?" He said, "Protestant." I said, "Me, too! What franchise?" He said, "Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Baptist or Southern Baptist?" He said, "Northern Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist or Northern Liberal Baptist?"

He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist." I said, "Me, too! Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region, or Northern Conservative Baptist Eastern Region?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region." I said, "Me, too!"

Northern Conservative†Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1879, or Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912?" He said, "Northern Conservative Baptist Great Lakes Region Council of 1912." I said, "Die, heretic!" And I pushed him over.

UNQUOTE

https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2005/sep/29/comedy.religion

Lisa Simeone's avatar

Such a great, if dispiriting, conversation. So many nails hit squarely on the head, too many excellent excerpts to quote.

I'm especially glad, though, to hear someone else use the comparison I've been using for years (and I'm sure she gets as much shit for it as I do): struggle sessions. She said Bruce went through a "mini struggle session." Yes. Exactly. And for all the supposed liberals who think that's hyperbolic, who still don't get it, I'll pull another of Carol's quotes -- such people have:

"A commitment to ignorance."

Jenny Poyer Ackerman's avatar

Those are two of my favorites as well.

Steersman's avatar

I can at least sympathize with Carol being "disfellowshiped" from her Unitarian group as my extended family did likewise by booting me out of their biweekly Zoom meeting. My crime? Merely emailing a link to a story about the For Women Scotland case before the UK Supreme Court which ruled that transwomen are most certainly not women -- such delicate souls.

Reminds me of a classic line, an amusing shot at the woke from NR:

"Our campuses turn young people into cultural hemophiliacs who, if someone bumps into them on the sidewalk, are likely to rupture a blood vessel and bleed out."

https://www.nationalreview.com/2020/06/strunk-and-white-racial-microaggressions-conde-naste-employee-quits/

However, this bit from Carol is somewhat "problematic" and exhibits the too-common "cognitive distortion" over the difference between sex and gender:

33:09 "Okay. Know what they always conclude? That you're non-binary. I am like 90 plus percent male."

That Carol exhibits some traits more typical of males like "standing up and stating your opinions and being a logical thinker" -- masculine traits -- doesn't make Carol into a male or any portion of one. All it means is that she is a female with some masculine traits, a masculine gender that she "identifies with", her "masculine gender identity".

Carol is a female because she has, or had, ovaries which is , more or less, the sine qua non to qualify as a member of that category. Exhibiting some masculine personality traits in no way abrogates or repudiates that brute fact.

Lisa Simeone's avatar

Steersman, yeah, you really do have to listen — and I say this as someone who would much rather read transcripts because it obviously takes less time — but that quote you pulled about Carol being “non-binary” — it’s totally out of context. She’s quoting some bullshit online “gender test” that told her she’s “non-binary.” She’s ridiculing the test and ridiculing the whole notion of being “non-binary.”

Carol Dansereau's avatar

The tests I took told me I was x% MALE. Their words, not mine. Thanks Lisa for correctly noting that I'm ridiculing the tests. The traits I have that land me in that category for the gender identitarians are neither male nor masculine. They're human traits that many but not all males have, and many but not all females have.

Steersman's avatar

Carol: "The traits I have that land me in that category for the gender identitarians are neither male nor masculine."

Given that you're something of a lawyer -- something I hadn't been aware of until Jenny pointed it out -- I wonder if you bothered to read my quote of the late great US Justice Anton Scalia which endorsed the use of "masculine" and "feminine" as genders, particularly useful since it captures the sexually dimorphic personality traits which you, yourself, have conceded are brute facts:

AS: "The word ‘gender’ has acquired the new and useful connotation of cultural or attitudinal characteristics … distinctive to the sexes. That is to say, gender is to sex as feminine is to female and masculine is to male."

https://jennypoyerackerman.substack.com/p/episode-41-featuring-carol-dansereau/comment/148252211

https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep511/usrep511127/usrep511127.pdf

Kind of think you're missing a bet, or are shooting yourself in the feet -- something the "gender-criticals", like Kara Dansky, are prone to doing -- by not "steelmanning" the concept of gender as Scalia has done.

The problem isn't with Scalia's conception of the term -- a fairly common one in fact -- but with the claim that gender is, or should be taken as equivalent to, sex. Rather risible on its face -- an absolute howler in fact -- at least starting from Scalia's take, to say, in effect and as an example, that some dude putting on a dress -- i.e., expressing a feminine gender -- is the same as having a pair of ovaries -- i.e., being a member of the female sex category:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender

You may know of, at least should know of, this suggestion by Justice Alito in the Skrmetti case:

CNN: "Justice Samuel Alito, in particular, was interested in the question of whether transgender status is 'immutable.' Historically, the court has considered immutability to be a key aspect of the characteristics of a group deserving of more protection."

https://www.cnn.com/politics/live-news/scotus-transgender-care-ban-12-04-24/index.html

Bit of a joke to talk about "transgender status being 'immutable' " when, as indicated, all a dude has to do to change his gender from masculine to feminine is to put on a dress -- or grow some bewbs or pay for a neovagina. Even apart from the impracticalities involved as there are probably as many genders as there are people since both "masculine" and "feminine" each qualify as a spectrum.

Different kettle of fish when we talk about the sexes since, to a first approximation, being male or female is simply a matter of having either testicles or ovaries -- more or less immutable, and each covers about 49% of the population. Though there are a few flies in even that ointment since some "biologists" (*cough Colin Wright *cough) claim that CAIS "girls" are still males:

"These CAIS 'Girls' are Males; So saith Colin Wright, so let it be done ..."

https://humanuseofhumanbeings.substack.com/p/these-cais-girls-are-males

Steersman's avatar

Ok -- you, and Jenny, may have a point; I may have misread that a bit: mea culpa, shoot me at dawn 🙂.

Though I still think it still highlights and justifies my point that those traits that Carol scored high on only make her more masculine and not "more" male -- only testicles would do that. Something that I think she should be more aware of since it drives the claims of many gender ideologues -- like Laurel Hubbard's demand to compete in women's sports because he had "transitioned to female".

You may wish to take a gander at this old Forbes article by transwoman Dawn Ennis as a case in point:

https://www.forbes.com/sites/dawnstaceyennis/2020/12/29/study-transgender-children-recognize-their-authentic-gender-at-early-age-just-like-other-kids/#20bbb14526bf

I think he is, like too many, conflating sex and gender which is what many court cases turn on.

Lisa Simeone's avatar

"those traits that Carol scored high on only make her more masculine and not more male."

Exactly.

Steersman's avatar

👍 Nice to see we're on the same page there. 🙂

Though you might point that out to Carol since she seems averse to any use of masculine and feminine, as genders, to denote or refer to various "sexually dimorphic" personality traits:

https://jennypoyerackerman.substack.com/p/episode-41-featuring-carol-dansereau/comment/148746443

But you both might consider this conversation I've had with "Hippiesq" -- like Carol, a lawyer, and, like Jenny, the mother of a dysphoric child -- on that perspective;

Hippiesq: If 'gender identity' were just the degree and specificity of feminine and masculine qualities, it might have some real usefulness in terms of being able to discuss differing personality traits — and maybe that was the origin of the term.

Hippiesq: We are what our biology tells us. That having been said, we each have our own mix of "masculine," "feminine," and more gender neutral characteristics that, as Steersman's quote from me indicates, could be said to be our "gender identity." Such an identity — which could change over time, or even day-to-day, and will change in accordance with differing societies that may consider different qualities as "masculine" or "feminine" — is intrinsic and personal and not subject to challenge.

https://humanuseofhumanbeings.substack.com/p/accidental-and-essential-properties

Jenny Poyer Ackerman's avatar

Appreciate the comment, but I would encourage listening rather than reading the transcript, as it seems to have led you far astray at 33:09. Be assured no one thinks Carol is either male or nonbinary. 🥹

Steersman's avatar

I find it takes less time to read the transcript, and it still tends to provide a better handle on what is said.

But if Carol is not a male -- I'll cheerfully concede that two kids of her own probably puts her solidly into the female category -- then i don't think she should be using "male" to describe having a masculine gender. Which is exactly what is in the transcript -- copied verbatim.

You may, with some reason, think that is a trivial point, but it seems that sloppy definitions, careless language, and obfuscatory terminology is part and parcel of the whole transgender clusterfuck. For example, I was defenestrated from Wikipedia for objecting to an article on transwoman and Olympian which claimed that "she" had "transitioned to female":

https://humanuseofhumanbeings.substack.com/p/wikipedias-lysenkoism

You might also have some interest in a quote therein of the late great US Justice Anton Scalia which draws a nice distinction between the categories of sex and gender -- entirely different kettles of fish which justifies separate terms:

AS: "The word ‘gender’ has acquired the new and useful connotation of cultural or attitudinal characteristics … distinctive to the sexes. That is to say, gender is to sex as feminine is to female and masculine is to male."

https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/usrep/usrep511/usrep511127/usrep511127.pdf

Susan Scheid's avatar

I so wish more people who are not already apprised of the harms of gender ideology would listen to this interview. What Carol Dansereau describes is extraordinarily common, and not something anyone espousing liberal values should support.

I want to note two of many moments that I thought particularly poignant.

First, Carol Dansereau described the consequences of hers and her husband’s expulsion from a community they had loved and supported for years:

“Because, you know, having been kicked out of our, this family camp we went to and the entire community that we enjoyed year round from it, I can tell you it is, and I'm sure you know this, but it is really hard. I hold my head up high and I would do exactly the same thing again. But, you know, I'm in my late 60s. My partner just turned 70. We just lost a major support network. And it is scary. You go into the older years without a support system or a greatly damaged support system. You feel vulnerable. Yeah. and you lose people who used to laugh and talk with you and make you feel good, you feel demoralized.”

The collateral damage arising out of this pernicious ideology is wide-ranging, and what Dansereau describes is an aspect that I’ve not heard anyone express before, but which is critically important.

Second, Jenny, is a question you asked Carol Dansereau:

“Do you have children who sort of led you into this? I don't know if you know anything about me, but that's why I find myself being obsessed with this is because I have a daughter who adopted a trans identity way back in 2016 when she was only 13. So I've been kind of in this rabbit hole for nine years. And I'm always so happy to see somebody who is as effective in doing the research and communicating the research and caring about this issue who maybe doesn't have to because you don't have personal skin in the game.”

The first time I met Hippiesq for lunch, she asked something similar of me. I’ve not forgotten how surprised I was by the question and have been thinking about it ever since.

As I noted, what Carol Dansereau explained about how scary it is, as she and her husband are getting older, to be cast out of an incredibly valuable support network, is yet another demonstration that the horrific effects of this pernicious ideology are deep and wide.

Here’s another example of those effects, one relevant to why I have been spurred to action, and about which I am enraged every single day. I was in law school at the University of Iowa from 1971-1974. Thereafter, I worked as a union organizer and on union staff for AFSCME in Iowa until moving to New York in 1979, when I took a position in the General Counsel’s Office of what was then ACTWU to work on the J. P. Stevens unionization campaign.

Just yesterday, on listening to the (delightful) Three Angry Lesbians conversation, I was led to think back on those heady days in Iowa and to recalling women I knew in Iowa City and what we collectively worked so hard to achieve. Here’s an excerpt from an interview with one of those women about those times, to give you a sense:

“So I referenced that Iowa City lesbian feminist community was incredibly vibrant, and we had, we had a whole little thriving sub-town inside the town. We had Iowa City Women’s Press, we had Ain’t I a Woman?, underground lesbian feminist newspaper that I was on the collective. We had two women’s collectives, living collectives. We had Grace & Ruby’s Restaurant. We had a bookstore. There was a food co-op, of course—friendly, but not ours. There was, we started the rape crisis line, we started the free medical clinic, we demonstrated. I remember demonstrating in—I think we sat in somewhere. We took over a building for the Women’s Center. The WRAC, the Women’s Resource and Action Center at the University of Iowa, which is still going strong today. So we, you know… Oh! We had a softball team, of course. We had a flag football team. We had, I mean, you know. We had, oh, at the Unitarian Church we had dances, we had plays. Someone wrote a lesbian feminist interpretation of The Taming of the Shrew, which is hard to do. And I played Petrucchio. I have pictures of this, which we put on in the basement of the Unitarian-Universalist Church in Iowa City. Without them, we would have had no, nothing. Everything happened at this church. And Meg Christian came there, and all the Olivia people, so, you know, lots… So there was this whole supportive environment.”

Because of gender ideology, all of this progress is being destroyed. This also constitutes skin in the game. Indeed, one of many things that is so bedevilling is that many, many more people have skin in the game than they realize. They may not yet have had a male sexual predator claiming to be a woman invade their locker room; they may not be aware what is being taught in their schools; and, of course, all too many remain unaware of the shoddy pseudo-science that props up medicalization of those who are sex-confused.

What we need to do, most of all, is incessant public education. As Ellie, co-founder of DIAG, recently said, “We have a ton of public educating to do. That is absolutely crucial. More important than anything else.”

Gretchen's avatar

When you were talking about losing your community because you asked questions and the loss you experienced I could feel with you. This is what all of us parents who have been shunned, silenced and abandoned by our adult ‘trans’ children are feeling. The loss of every holiday, every birthday, of all the things that feel meaningful in our family relationships. It’s like falling off a cliff into an abyss of loneliness.

Susan Scheid's avatar

I haven't yet finished listening to this superb, thoughtful conversation, but I wanted, before I forget, to drop a note that the academic Dansereau is likely thinking of who opined about why women aren't good at science was Larry Summers. Here's a link to an article describing what he said: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2005/jan/18/educationsgendergap.genderissues

Also, and related to that, Theda Skocpol, now a tenured full professor at Harvard, was initially denied tenure. In the year she was denied tenure, only 12 of 356 tenured faculty were women. Here's an article about all of that: https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2006/6/5/denied-tenure-skocpol-alleged-sexual-discrimination/